Reviewer Guideline – IJSESM

WANT TO JOIN OUR REVIEWER TEAM

Reviewer Guidelines

Review Assignment

Confidentiality: Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process. Do not disclose any details of the manuscript or review process to others.

Conflict of Interest: If you have any conflicts of interest related to the manuscript, including personal, financial, or professional connections to the authors, notify the editorial office immediately and recuse yourself from the review.

Review Process

Timeliness: Review the manuscript within the time frame provided. If you require additional time, contact the editorial office as soon as possible.

Scope of Review: Assess the manuscript’s originality, significance, methodological rigor, clarity, and contribution to the field. Consider whether the study advances knowledge in the social sciences.

Review Criteria

Reviewers should assess the relevance, originality, and scholarly contribution of the manuscript to the International Journal of Sustainability in Engineering, Science and Management. They should also evaluate the research methodology, data analysis, and validity of the conclusions presented.

In addition, reviewers should ensure that the manuscript is clearly written, well-structured, and supported by accurate and relevant references. Attention should also be given to language quality, organization, and overall academic standards.

Paper Feedback

Reviewers are encouraged to provide clear, constructive, and detailed feedback to help authors improve the quality of their manuscripts by highlighting both strengths and areas requiring improvement. Based on the evaluation, reviewers should recommend one of the following decisions: Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject.

All review comments shared with authors must remain professional, objective, and respectful. Reviewers should avoid personal remarks and maintain confidentiality and anonymity throughout the peer-review process.

Ethical Considerations

Ethical Standards: Ensure that the manuscript adheres to ethical standards, including proper citation practices, ethical treatment of research subjects, and transparency in reporting.

Data Integrity: Be vigilant for signs of data manipulation, fabrication, or plagiarism. Report any concerns to the editorial office.

Revision and Decision

Follow-up: If the manuscript is returned to the authors for revisions, review the revised manuscript to ensure that all your comments and suggestions have been addressed.

Editorial Decision: The final decision on the manuscript will be made by the editor based on your review and the feedback from other reviewers. Your recommendation will be a key factor in this decision.

Confidentiality and Ethics

Review Confidentiality: Do not discuss or share information about the manuscript or the review process with anyone outside of the review process.

Ethical Review: Follow ethical guidelines for reviewing manuscripts and ensure a fair and unbiased assessment.

APPLY AS REVIEWER

Submit Research Paper

Peer-Reviewed, Crossref Indexed Journal

IJSESM is a monthly, peer-reviewed, open-access journal publishing high-quality research in engineering, science, and technology, indexed by CrossRef and Scholarly with a high impact factor of 8.6.

IJSESM publishes high-quality research articles, review papers, and short communications in engineering, science, and technology. The journal offers rapid peer review, fast publication, free DOI assignment, and complimentary publication certificates for authors

Authors benefit from low publication fees, open access, global visibility, simple submission, online tracking, and dedicated editorial support. Gain wider recognition, increased citations, and trusted academic exposure worldwide when you publish with us.